Showing posts with label waste. Show all posts
Showing posts with label waste. Show all posts


Design seems to center more as design FOR developing countries, instead of design IN developing countries. The design process is short and depends on the free time of the designer as the goal of the whole project is to merely develop a product, whether good or bad. Also, generally these projects by foreigners lean on the high-tech side rather than user-centric design. If it was a longer term project, it would have to involve local capacity, skills, knowledge and expertise that enables the society to meet their own needs. However generally, locals do not have the skills or experience to support these projects (Kass, 2013).

Bill Gates’ charity foundation was able to successfully promote awareness of poor sanitation conditions in third world countries, and in order to help solve the issue he hosted a competition for a Toilet design that could be implemented in Third World countries. However, the winning project was far too costly and overly technical to be feasable (Donaldson, 2008).

It is clear that the design had little understanding of the real needs of and did not design with environment (materials and user knowledge) in mind. The winning design of the competition consisted of a toilet designed by CalTech that wouldn’t be economically feasible. Most toilet entries had additional high tech “cool” factor items which would be extremely impractical in the environments in which they were supposed to be implemented. Their approach focused on a similar problem faced by North Americans- lack of access to established septic systems- but ignored dissimilar problems faced by third-world users such as poverty (Donaldson, 2008).

While design projects like this are often well intentioned, they can be very impractical in the long-run. Rather than attempt to design a "cool" product with high-tech "innovative" solutions, the projects should focus on being low cost, low maintenance and practical material use.



Why This is Important:

Projects from NGO's are not always successful. For example, an American NGO built a water harvesting system in Malawi. It broke down. Several years later, Engineers Without Borders built a nearly identical system. Again, it broke down. It is incredibly important that we learn from past mistakes and are aware of the history of projects in the area. Furthermore, it is important that anything we build is understood by and can be maintained by people in Longido.


Resources:



Kass, J. (2013, November 18). Bill Gates Can’t Build a Toilet. Retrieved September 15, 2014.

Donaldson, K. (2008, January 1). Why to be Wary of “Design for Developing Countries”. Thinking, 35-37.


Some villagers of different parts of Tanzania scrounge the Arusha City Dump for coveted glass, plastic bottles, tin cans and scrap metal to collect and sell. The dump allows for the unemployed to earn a living, gaining enough to survive. A thing they lack is the protective clothing such as gloves and glasses that help them continue this job safely. A villager, originally from the Kilimanjaro region uses the money he earns scavenging to help take care of his family and pay school fees. 

These materials can be sold to various enterprises for money such as Maendelo Plastic who then sell to other enterprises such as A to Z Textile Mills Ltd.

The villagers request government help as the working environment is littered with dangerous chemicals, disease and sharp edges.

Sorting your trash: A responsible and worthy endeavor. (2011, October 2). Retrieved October 8, 2014, from http://www.rttz.org/sorting-your-trash-a-responsible-and-worthy-endeavor/


Stephen Obuya, a father of three and a resident of Sombetini in Tanzania, has successfully started an agribusiness where he converted a land originally used as a garbage dump site and had reclaimed it into a garden. There he grows kale with the help of a mechanically operated irrigation pump, a device manufactured in Arusha.

With the garden, Obuya lets fellow villagers harvest the amount of kale they want off his garden and are able to pay for. This way he has achieved an average income of about Sh38,400 (Tsh 691,200) as oppose to Sh4,500-Sh5,000 (approx. Tsh81,000).

The "Moneymaker pump" is a design by a non-profit organization called Kickstart who work to develop  solutions to aid small-scale farmers and how to improve their food production using simple irrigation systems. These systems are mechanically operated and therefore do not need gasoline, which make them cheaper to operate. The construction of these systems are very simple and easily repairable, lasting 3 years before needing any maintenance. These pumps go for around Sh8,800 (Tsh158,400). To expensive to buy for some people, villagers have bought systems and have them leased out.

The Moneymaker pumps allow for excess food production which farmers can then sell. Obuya specifically sets aside 95% of his harvest for sale while the rest is for his families consumption.

Besides using the system for water harvesting for his garden, Obuya also uses the system to make brick.

"Nearly all the farmers using the machines prefer to grow vegetables because they take less time to mature, require small area to grow and have high turnover in monetary sales." - Pendo, a female farmer.

Kebaso, G. (2012, October 31). Garbage site turns into bread basket in Tanzania.Agriculture. Retrieved October 8, 2014, from http://www.kickstart.org/news/Garbage site turns into bread basket in Tanzania - Oct. 31, 2012- full article.pdf




Terrariums are self sustaining mini-ecosystems. Once they have been built than can essentially be “forgotten about” and will continue to grow and exist without further interaction from the user, save for the occasional check up or cleaning. Ideally, a closed terrarium doesn't need to be opened. Open terrariums do exist, and may require more care – but the plants selected for such environments (such as cacti) do not require frequent interaction.

They work on the principle of recycling water constantly. the water in the system does not leave, allowing for "rain" in the form of condensation. Water in the soil travels through the roots  into the plat. the plant "perspires" releasing water into the air. The evaporated water from the leaves and soil forms condensation on the walls of the terrarium and drips back into the soil starting the process over. Their may be a way to use the principles of the water cycle to create a sustainable agriculture solution that minimizes the amount of water that needs to be added.

Green Houses borrow some properties from terrariums; they are a closed environment that sustains a specific ecosystem / temperature/ moisture level etc. However, they are designed to allow the user to enter the system frequently to care for the plants or retrieve items.

Another simple idea I have is terrariums as a teaching tool. A small scale terrarium could be easily created from a water bottle, earth (soil), and gravel. Charcoal is available in Longido and is often a layer used in terrariums, but is not necessary for the terrarium to work.  These layers could be placed in a plastic bottle, a seed planted inside, and then sealed. Through this process children could learn about the water cycle and how to grow their own plants.

There is also a possibility to use this process to allow people to begin the growth of a plant in a terrarium then replant it in a garden to allow it to grow further for agricultural purposes.


There is an opportunity to look into plastic bottles as materials to build greenhouses and agricultural aids on a small scale in Longido. Greenhouses on a large scale are currently being employed in Tanzania. Benno Ngjovu, a local farmer, has taken to green house farming as a solution to the extreme dry season. There may be a method of employing greenhouse techniques and water irrigation on a smaller scale to allow for individuals or small communities to build their own garden farms (African Farming, 2012).
The farm, which is in its initial stage, is expected to produce tomatoes worth US$12,738 per week after six months. Tanzanian agricultural entrepreneur and farmer Benno Ndjovu said he had invested US$4,458 to construct the plastic greenhouse, fitted with a drip water irrigation system.
"The advantages of greenhouse farming is that production goes on throughout the year and does not depend on rain. The risk of diseases is also lower compared to open farming," Ndjovu pointed out.

Bottles as building blocks!
Pop Bottle Greenhouse - John Rutherford (2011)


Why This is Important: 

At one point Virginia Taylor had mentioned that Greenhouses were an area for design exploration for Longido. There may be an opportunity for a greenhouse that preserves the humidity / water without allowing it to evaporate (in a terrarium fashion). One major concern I have about green houses is the heat build up, and I'm not sure how well plants would survive in a closed in environment. This is an area I intend to look into further.



Resources:

Rutherford, J. (2011) Pop Bottle Greenhouse [Photo] Retrieved October 3, 2014. From: https://www.flickr.com/photos/fairleyforge/6108421928/

African Farming (2012) Tanzanian farmer demonstrates potential of greenhouse farming. Retrieved October 3, 2014. From: http://www.africanfarming.net/crops/agriculture/tanzanian-farmer-demonstrates-potential-of-greenhouse-farming
  • Karatu is a 2 hour drive from Longido
  • There is no municipal waste collection in Karatu, so they collect all the garbage in a pile and burn it, which sometimes causes a giant smoke to cover the town
  • The people don't have a lot so they cannot burn a lot so it really isn't that bad 
  • Not an academic source, but it's a blog written by someone who is living there right now 
       Garbage Day in Karatu. (2011, June 20). Experience Rural Tanzania CPAR U of M Students. Retrieved September 22, 2014, from http://experienceruraltanzania.wordpress.com/2011/06/20/garbage-day-in-karatu/ 


A permaculture project



Testigo Projects Inc. is a not-for-profit association whose goal is to empower people by creating a positive and sustainable community around progressive water, food, and adult educational practices. 

"Testigo Africa is teaching Masai women and men to grow their own food for the first time using permaculture principles. Ukuaji is the Swahili word for 'grow' - growing food, growing people."

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BIzVeDHi9e4



Testigo Africa. Retrieved from http://www.testigoafrica.org/

Testigo Africa. (2014, August 11). Testigo Africa's Ukuaji (Short Version) Permaculture Project [Video File]. Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BIzVeDHi9e4


"In typical Maasai households, women have to walk 5-10 kilometers (3-6 miles) for a bucket of water. Imagine if an entire village had water storage facilities at each household, safe and affordable for all, reducing labor and time to fetch water, enabling the luxury of an occasional bath, and if purified, water for cooking and cleansing, thus reducing disease incidence."

 Source: http://www.globalservicecorps.org/site/hafirs

The Bright Spot:

In Longido, a 48-year-old-mother of three, grandmother of seven, has been successfully growing vegetables throughout the dry season. She has been using a Hafir to collect water from natural rain sources. This device along with her double dug vegetable beds allowed her to grow vegetables for her self with enough left over to sell. She says “During the dry season, I used to have to purchase water for 2000 tsh per bucket, which wasn’t even enough to do the house chores, so I never had any water for a vegetable garden; but now with my hafir, I have water available for free, even during the dry season.”  Even with a modest turnover, she has begun an entrepreneurial service of selling her organic vegetables.
Source: http://globalservicecorpsblog.wordpress.com/2012/10/23/transformation-in-dry-longido/

The Technology:

" Children collecting water from a haffir: Children collect water from a local reservoir 
(called a "hafir") which fills up after the rains. 
The water is dirty and unsafe for drinking,
 but water shortages mean it is sometimes all people have." 
 Photo credit: Alun McDonald


A hafir is a reservoir system that uses a trench lined with plastic sheeting to collect rain water. Small scale Hafirs can be built for households to collect water, allowing them to collect enough water for vegetable gardens all year round. Global Service Corps (GSC) has been working with local companies to built these water cisterns in Lashaina Village, Monduli. Additionally, they have been provided educational and training services to help local people begin growing their own garden on their own property,

Source: http://www.globalservicecorps.org/site/hafirs

Why This is Important:

This represents a "bright spot" - something that is already working that we as designers can build upon. It is important to be sure that our designs and solutions make use of familiar technologies and use methods that locals will be able to understand and maintain. The use of water reservoirs such as hafirs along with agriculture presents the opportunities for micro-enterprises and sustainable food growth through sustainable water use.

Sources:

MacDonald, Alun. (2013). Children collecting water from a haffir [Photograph], Retrieved September 19,Year. from: https://www.flickr.com/photos/oxfameastafrica/9089760975/

Transformation in Dry Longido. (2012, October 23). Retrieved September 19, 2014, from http://globalservicecorpsblog.wordpress.com/2012/10/23/transformation-in-dry-longido/

Hafir Water Catchment Project: Addressing the Water Challenge in Maasailand. (2008, January 1). Retrieved September 19, 2014, from http://www.globalservicecorps.org/site/hafirs

http://www.inspirationgreen.com/plastic-bottle-homes.html

Here are some innovative ways that people have made use of recycled materials as building materials! Check out the link for more images.

Around the world, people are employing plastic and glass bottles as building blocks.
source: http://www.inspirationgreen.com/plastic-bottle-homes.html



All over the world, people have begun to look at waste as materials. The method is currently being used by several organizations and individuals alike, including Eco-Tech

A man in Sabon Yelwa, Nigeria builds a wall with "bottle bricks."

For an area of the world, where housing is expensive and waste is plentiful, this clever building method may be the solution. First, it simplifies the building materials - bricks are labor intensive to make and this method only requires filling a bottle with sand. Secondly, it takes an item that would normally be discarded and gives it new life.



Why This is Important:

Brick building was identified as an area of difficulty, and a time consuming, water consuming and labor intensive activity. With trash and bottles being far too common in Longido, this may present an opportunity to solve both the brick building and waste problem. When building homes, this could be used and redesigned to suit the cultural context in Longido. 
This innovative building material can be employed in many areas beyond house building. It could be used in building any other structures including community spaces, furniture, playgrounds, garden beds & agricultural planters, and could potentially be used for water reservoirs. This method is a great source of inspiration for many different topics within the scope of our project.



Sources:

Abubakar, A. (2011) Plastic bottles solve Nigeria's housing problem. PHY.ORG. Retrieved September 9, 2014. From: http://phys.org/news/2011-11-plastic-bottles-nigeria-housing-problem.html



Powered by Blogger.